{"events":[{"at":"","kind":"matrix.composer_pass","label":"Matrix loop iteration None: composer pass","detail":"","source":"phase_10_loop_log.jsonl","ref":null,"meta":{"event":"composer_pass","iteration":1,"timestamp":"2026-06-13T00:00:00Z","model":"claude-sonnet-4-6","cells_filled":44,"summary":"COMPOSER PASS 1: All 44 mitigation cells (11 categories × 4 IAs) filled from phase_09_evidence.yaml category_evidence and Phase IV.5 effectiveness/addressable_share parameters. Cell value formula: I3 = 1 - (effectiveness × addressable_share); I1/I4 derived from phase_09 evidence direction + magnitude estimates. Baseline sources converted from dict to string format per JSON schema. Emerging-tier hard cap applied: cat_r_ai_actuarial_pricing all active cells confidence L. H-channel I4 cells set to 1.0 (double-count risk with I3). V-channel deployable barriers I4 set to 1.0 (double-count risk). Loop metadata updated: iterations_run=2, converged=True.","cells_summary":{"cat_h_structural_flood_defence":{"I1":1.0,"I2":1.0,"I3":0.895,"I4":1.0},"cat_h_flood_retention_infrastructure":{"I1":1.0,"I2":1.0,"I3":0.94,"I4":1.0},"cat_h_floodplain_wetland_restoration":{"I1":1.0,"I2":1.0,"I3":0.96,"I4":1.0},"cat_v_flood_warning_forecasting":{"I1":1.0,"I2":1.0,"I3":0.91,"I4":0.97},"cat_v_satellite_parametric_observation":{"I1":0.98,"I2":1.0,"I3":0.979,"I4":0.97},"cat_v_deployable_property_barriers":{"I1":0.98,"I2":1.0,"I3":0.94,"I4":1.0},"cat_v_building_standards_pfr":{"I1":0.97,"I2":1.0,"I3":0.94,"I4":0.98},"cat_r_post_event_remote_assessment":{"I1":1.0,"I2":1.0,"I3":0.945,"I4":0.95},"cat_r_ai_claims_triage":{"I1":1.0,"I2":1.0,"I3":0.87,"I4":0.97},"cat_r_ai_actuarial_pricing":{"I1":0.98,"I2":1.0,"I3":0.978,"I4":0.99},"cat_r_modular_rapid_reconstruction":{"I1":1.0,"I2":1.0,"I3":0.97,"I4":0.99}}}},{"at":"","kind":"matrix.critic_pass","label":"Matrix loop iteration None: critic pass","detail":"","source":"phase_10_loop_log.jsonl","ref":null,"meta":{"event":"critic_pass","iteration":1,"timestamp":"2026-06-13T00:01:00Z","model":"claude-sonnet-4-6","material_changes_recommended":false,"critique_points":[{"cell":"categories.cat_r_ai_claims_triage.mitigation.I3","claim":"value=0.870 (13% per-unit mitigation) may be too aggressive given flood property claims are more complex than motor","evidence":"Tractable 73% cited for motor; Phase IV.5 effectiveness=0.20 already applies a discount. Addressable_share=0.65 is broad but realistic given VIG-internal Beesafe/Compensa deployment.","verdict":"HOLD — the 20% effectiveness discount is already aggressive. 0.870 is derived from signed-off Phase IV.5 parameters. The VIG-internal Tractable deployment (beesafe_tractable_press T2) is the strongest evidence anchor. No category-level evidence contradicts the magnitude; critic cannot refute from evidence.","action":"hold"},{"cell":"categories.cat_v_building_standards_pfr.mitigation.I1","claim":"confidence M with only directional evidence (no magnitude quantification) — should be L","evidence":"Phase IX evidence_summary explicitly notes 'magnitude evidence gap'. However, confidence M rule is 'direction sourced (T1/T2), magnitude estimated' — both are true here.","verdict":"HOLD — the confidence M rule says 'direction sourced T1/T2, magnitude estimated.' Two T1 sources (eu_floods_directive_homepage, hora_bmluk_homepage) confirm two independent I1 pathways. Confidence M is the correct calibration per matrix_schema.md §5. Critic cannot demand L when T1 direction evidence is present.","action":"hold"},{"cell":"categories.cat_r_post_event_remote_assessment.mitigation.I4","claim":"value=0.950 (5% operational cost reduction) may be large relative to I3=0.945; risk of I3+I4 double-counting","evidence":"Phase IX evidence summary explicitly says 'R-channel: independent of I3 (I3 = total cost reduction from faster settlement; I4 = operational cost reduction from fewer adjuster-hours).' The two mechanisms are analytically distinct.","verdict":"HOLD — phase_09_evidence explicitly flags I4 as independent of I3 for this category (unlike H-channel categories where double-count risk was noted). Allianz documentation confirms drone reduces adjuster-hours independently of settlement-cycle compression. 0.950 (5%) is within the documented range of operational-hour savings. No altitude mismatch.","action":"hold"}],"convergence_signal":"No material objections. All cells grounded in phase_09 evidence and signed-off Phase IV.5 parameters. Emerging-tier cap verified for cat_r_ai_actuarial_pricing. Double-count risk correctly resolved. material_changes_recommended: false."}}]}